Category: Ramblings

Nov 04 2014

Jodorowsky’s Dune

I’ve mentioned before that I consider Frank Herbert one of my Three Pillars and that the Dune series has had a profound impact on me and my writing. I’ve also discussed how I studied adaptation of the written word in grad school. One of the main themes of the course was stories that are “unadaptable”, that is, ill-suited for the screen for one reason or another. Working out the how and why a particular story could be considered unadaptable was a decent chunk of our in-class discussions. Anyway, I bring all this up because if ever there was a story that was unadaptable, Dune is it. If you’ve seen the David Lynch version (or its Alan Smithee variant), you know that it was a mess. There are some good points to it, but it misses the mark by a wide margin. I thought the mini series made by the Sci-Fi Channel was better as an adaptation, but still came up short. I honestly don’t think the gap can be overcome, though I could potentially see it working in animation. Working better, at any rate, in the right hands, of course. A 13- or even 26-ep series would probably do the trick. All that aside, I want to talk about the first attempt to bring Dune to the silver screen as chronicled in the documentary Jodorowsky’s Dune, which I watched last week.

Alejandro Jodorowsky is something of an experimental filmmaker and at a friend’s recommendation, he decided to make the leap from arthouse indie flicks to a a big-budget magnum opus with Dune. I highly recommend the documentary, so I’m not going to hash out everything that it covers. What I am going to say is how intrigued I was at Jodorowsky’s concept, the years of work he sunk into it and the grand assemblage of talent he was pulling together. Salvador Dali as the Padishah Emperor, Orson Welles as Baron Harkonnen… That’s just scratching the surface. Each step of the story seems more impossible than the last and the amazing thing is how far Jodorowsky actually got. It was an impossible vision and the final result was inevitable. Still, it’s amazing to see and the aftermath isn’t nearly as dire as you might think.

My all too brief treatment doesn’t come anywhere close to doing the material justice, but in conclusion, check out Jodorowsky’s Dune. It’s a real trip. In more ways than one. ^_^

Dec 16 2013

On Adapting the Written Word

Although I’m content to let things drop with regards to The Desolation of Smaug, there’s a wider issue not really covered in my critique of the film that would likely be used against me if anyone cared to rebut my post. That issue is adaptational fidelity.

Let’s start by setting up where I began on the issue. I was once the most die-hard of purists. In another life, I would compose these massive posts comparing the Inuyasha anime to the original manga with copious scans and such minute detail that even a single word changed in the script didn’t go unnoted. I was often decried by the more loosey-goosey members of the fandom as a “manga thumper”. (Yes, that was really a thing, and, yes, we were all incredible nerds.)

I say this is where I began because my views have matured over the years. No small contributor was a course on adapting the written word I took in grad school. I came to fully acknowledge the differences among media and appreciate pragmatic adaptation. The spirit of the word is more important than the letter of the word when it comes to true fidelity. Herein lies the problem.

You see, it’s not uncommon for an adaptation to fundamentally misunderstand the source material. For instance, when watching the special features for Return of the King, I was appalled to hear that they were wanting to have a fight scene between Aragorn and a physical manifestation of Sauron. The whole point of LOTR is that it isn’t Aragorn who’s the real hero of the story, even though he almost perfectly fits conventional expectations. It’s Frodo and Sam who are the real heroes. Upending those conventional expectations of the heroic epic was at the very heart of the story. The fact that they almost went that far off the rails makes the disappointing developments of TDoS not all that surprising.

I don’t claim that any of this is easy. The transition between a project that is largely contained and directed by a single person to a massive undertaking involving dozens of people is no easy task. There are a host of considerations at work and competing visions shaping the final product. I can appreciate a measure of pragmatism as necessary and even a good thing, but when the adapters miss the mark, it can be really disheartening. It’s the risk you run when you adapt a work from one medium to another. I recall one writer who commented that if you want a movie deal, you just sign away the rights, cash the check and let the chips fall where they may. I doubt I’ll ever be presented with that opportunity, but I’d be reluctant to just let go like that. I’m too much of a control freak for that and would just as soon forego any adaptations rather than risk my vision being warped. Maybe any interested parties can wait until after I’m dead. ^_^;

Dec 14 2013

The Desolation of a Franchise

Okay, I’ve slept on it and I’ve come to a conclusion: I hate The Desolation of Smaug. Let’s turn back the clock a bit. When I heard The Hobbit was being made into two movies, I was a little concerned. When those two movies became three, I grew even more concerned. This is Peter Jackson, after all, which meant three-hour movies. A 300-page book spread out over nine hours? Yeah, we’re going to have a pointless scene with Smaug and Naomi Watts playing in the snow. However, when I saw An Unexpected Journey, I was pleased with the integration of materials from The Unfinished Tales and the stronger buildup to the LotR trilogy. The movie was still a little longer than it needed to be, but I was satisfied with it.

However, even with material from the periphery to expand the narrative, what happens when all that runs short? How do you fill the gaps? Well, The Desolation of Smaug answers that question. With bad fanfic.

Much of what is terrible about TDoS centers around the character of Tauriel. When I heard there was brewing controversy around this OC female Elven warrior, I didn’t pay it much heed. Now, before I go into this rant, let’s set something straight for any cuckleheads out there. I’m not opposed to strong female characters. I love strong female characters. I love ’em in the fiction I consume and the fiction I create. What I don’t like is poorly executed “strong” female charas. For instance, one of the more loathsome things about Van Helsing is faux action girl Anna (a rant for another day). In Tauriel’s case, being a canon foreigner stacks the deck against her right out of the gate, but that isn’t her mortal sin. Her mortal sin is being the Suest of Mary Sues this side of Bella friggin’ Swan. Let’s lay it all out. We won’t count her beauty on the Sue card because all Elves are supposed to be beautiful. So we’ve got a cool female warrior who’s not just a low-ranker struggling to prove herself in a male-dominated society. No, she’s the Captain of Guard. But, hey, she’s lowborn, so she’s just like us. Also, she’s not like all those other racist, isolationist Elves. She cares about the outside world and is tolerant of other races. She’ll stand up mean ol’ Thranduil and rebel against him to do what’s right, doggonit. Oh, and let’s not forget about the romance. Even if there’s the class difference, she’s got that dreamboat Legolas to pine and be pined for (though, admittedly, any romantic subtext between those two was about as clear as mud). And because we can’t have an Edward without a Jacob, she’s also got the dreamiest of the Dwarves fall for her. Yeah, he’s a stubby ol’ Dwarf, but he’s just a little taller and instead of one of those nappy beards, he’s got that smexy bad-boy permastubble. Oh, and it’s a deep emotional connection, too. Starlight and stuff. Also, in addition to her near flawless warrior skills, she’s also a talented healer, too. What a perfect pretty progressive princess.

Merciful Heaven, where do I begin? I don’t even know. I’m not the certain of person to delve into fanfiction, but if Tauriel doesn’t feel like a self-insert OC, I don’t know what does. She was made for the express purpose of shoehorning in a female character into the story. They showed signs of trying to do this with Arwen in Fellowship, but that idea was mercifully killed in the cradle. Using her in place of Glorfindel was a pragmatic adaptation and I let it slide. A lot of people go on about the dearth of strong female charas in the Tolkien mythos. Well, guess what? An author in the 40’s writing in the model of 8th Century epics. Who’s surprised? Not me. Trying force modern sensibilities on such material is just asinine.

While we’re on the topic of feminism, let’s talk some feminism. Tauriel is clearly meant as progressive pandering, but guess what? Her character is entirely wrapped up in her love interests, Legolas and Kili. I’d say that fails the Bechdel Test, but I suppose it requires two females. I’d like to believe that the true goal of feminism is to give females their fair shot based on their ability and talents. In other words, the end game should be that so long as the ability is there, it shouldn’t matter if a male or a female is in the slot. However, Tauriel has been so deliberately engineered that it’s downright offensive. And you want to know the real kicker? I probably wouldn’t mind the character half as much in any generic fantasy story. It’s her imposition that is such a large part of the problem.

I’m going to make a rather bold statement here. Tauriel is worse than Jar-Jar Binks. Yeah, I went there. They’ve got more in common than you might think. Both are intrusions in an established canon that the director thought was a terribly good idea. However, at least with Jar-Jar, everyone in universe recognized he was a fool and we could sympathize with Qui-Gon’s annoyance. There was some self-awareness and terrible comic relief is practically expected because comic relief character tend to miss more often than they hit. With Tauriel, we’re supposed to take her seriously and that’s what makes her worse. This original character gets grafted in and we’re all supposed to love her for what a special super snowflake she is. Well, I’m not buying what you’re selling.

Moving on to the romantic plot tumor, I mentioned in an earlier parenthetical that the romantic relationship between Tauriel and Legolas was largely informed. Yes, we hear a lot about how Legolas cares for her, but all I really saw was aloof contempt. (Legolas was rather unlikable in the film. Shoehorning him in wasn’t a great idea either.) The main event was the Tauriel/Kili ship, which was terrible. I’ve heard about being strangled by the red string, but this is the first time I’ve physically felt my own neck go taut just observing a crappy romantic subplot play out. Ugh…

Let’s go back to where I was talking about Jar-Jar. I’m a Star Wars fan. I actually enjoyed the prequels more than I didn’t, though I don’t rewatch them regularly like I do the Original Trilogy (theatrical cut, of course, because screw all the extra crap from ’97 on). Episode I was the worst of the three, of course, primarily on account of Jar-Jar, but Jake Lloyd’s Anakin wasn’t much better (I actually kinda feel sorry for him now that I know what the role did to him and his career). Anyway, the point is that I kept watching and though I completely ignored the theatrical Clone Wars film, I’ll be there in the theaters 2015 to give Episode VII its fair shake. You know where I won’t be in 2014? In the theaters to see There and Back Again. TDoS killed it for me. I actually wanted to leave the theater but decided I was going to get my $10 worth for better or worse. I’ve seen some bad movies before, but I never wanted to get up and leave the theater. Even friggin’ Transformers 2 I sat through, dagnabbit. My grandmother and I have a tradition of watching the LotR movies in the theater going back to The Two Towers (I was stationed in Italy when Fellowship came out, you see), but this year I’m going to break that tradition. I don’t want to see TDoS again. I’m not going to see it again and I’m not going to see Numero Tres either.

Now, I could end on that, but let’s talk a little about the positive. Martin Freeman’s performance? Outstanding. Same goes for Benedict Cumberbatch as Smaug. If you just skip to the climb up the Lonely Mountain, you might have a good time. Naturally, WETA’s work is top-notch, though they go a little too over-the-top and so it looks a bit fakier than in previous films.

Bottom line: Stretching The Hobbit out to three movies was a mistake. Tauriel is a terrible character. I want Peter Jackson to pay me $5. (The aforementioned performances of Freeman and Cumberbatch are at least worth half the ticket price.) And I’m done, on so many levels.

Nov 02 2013

Atmospheric Fog

While I was heading out to see Ender’s Game last night, I saw something interesting. We’ve recently had some heavy rains and last night we had a thick fog. At first I was making jokes to myself like, “What’s with this draw distance? It’s like I’m playing Turok. I half expect some blocky velociraptor to come at me.” Then I started to realize just how creepy it was.

With such low visibility, I was naturally going slower than usual, which drew out the drive. With the regularly spaces trees and lightposts, the road seemed to go on forever. Then I took a turn onto the highway and there wasn’t a light one to bed seen for a good half mile. I thought, “Man, this is where stuff goes down.” Fortunately, no stuff did go down, but I got a nice visceral sense of the atmospheric quality of fog. I’ll certainly have to remember it.

Nov 01 2013

Don’t Mine at Night (Unless You Like Being Sleep-Deprived)

You’re probably wondering what’s happened to me. Minecraft. That’s what’s happened.

I first heard about Minecraft when it was still in development. I tried the demo of the beta and was going to make a point to get it once the full version was released, but I never did. Even so, I’ve been watching Achievement Hunter’s Minecraft vids ever since I heard of Plan G and the recent foray into Galacticraft seems to have been critical mass for me. I purchased the game Saturday evening and no small portion of my waking hours since have been devoted to it. (You’d think after the Fantasica debacle, I’d show a little more sense, but, alas, I have not.) Minecraft takes hold of my love of collecting, exploring and building in a perfect maelstrom that consumes much of my time and brainpower.

When I created my first world, I wasn’t used to the controls and it ended poorly. You see, I’m used to using the keyboard only for PC games (except an RTS like Starcraft), which was fine 20 years ago, but you can’t get around the keyboard and mouse requirement and once I stopped fighting and learned the controls, things picked up. It was entirely unnecessary, but I deleted and recreated the world to start over.

Kronos 04 has proven to be an interesting planet. I appeared on a small island with nothing but ocean as far as the eye could see. I dug in for shelter and slowly began exploring the depths while fortifying my new home, Ithaca. Penelope’s Wall was raised around the island to seal it off from the ravening hordes. After uncovering the cavern I codenamed Area Zulu, I had to beware the monsters of the depths. Taking advantage of the fact that I was on an island I flooded the tunnels to keep the beasts at bay. The island was too small to support wildlife, so I pretty well had to resign myself to starving with only the occasional apple from the oak trees or the rotting flesh of zombies for sustenance. In addition to filling the island with trees, I slowly began to build a farm that made bread a possibility. After a failed mining expedition where all the fruits of my labors were lost to the lava, I committed myself to the construction of my great sanctuary, the Tower of Telemachus. (Somehow a creeper still managed to slip into the chamber over 130 feet in the air. >_>)

Yesterday I finally dared the endless blue in search of new lands. My search has been quite fruitful and I have established new forward operating bases to extend my reach. However, beyond the Wall’s safety, I found myself far more vulnerable to the depredations of the creatures of the night. Some of my acquisitions were saved and some were lost, but soon I’ll tighten my grip on the new territories and unite my empire. Until then, I hunt, I gather, I mine, I build.

Oct 25 2013

Don’t Sleep Where You Work

The above is a bit of a variation of the common if rather vulgar expression warning against mixing tasks in a certain location, but I’m sure you all could tell that.

You see, I tend to sit on the couch while I do my work on my laptop. I also have a habit of taking naps on said couch. As I’ve mentioned before in the previous Rambling post “The Night Owl Crashes and Burns”, my new exercise regimen has a way of sapping my energy and putting me right out. I’m sure that my body being conditioned to sleep on the couch (to say nothing of my borderline narcolepsy) contribute to this.

I remember reading an article way back when advising against reading or doing other similar tasks in bed because it disrupts your body’s conditioning to associate the bed with sleep. Whether this is true or not, I surely couldn’t say, but it would seem that there’s something to it. Of course, I’ve also crashed out in my office chair as well, so I think a hypersomniac like myself has to resign himself to falling asleep pretty much anywhere at the slightest inducement.

Anyway, long story short, that’s why I haven’t posted any progress the last couple days. Oh, I suppose I wrote half a sentence two days ago, but I can hardly count that. Maybe I can do better over the weekend. We’ll see.

Oct 11 2013

Confessions of a Gaming Addict

Hello. My name is James and I’m a gaming addict.

Group: Hi, James.

If you’ve been following me on Twitter (not exactly the ideal platform for long discourses, though I have a habit of treating it like my IM with the world), then you’ve heard me talk about my general disillusionment with gaming, which was once a major part of my life and continues to hold some influence, though I’ve largely “grown up” as someone close to me has said on the matter.

You may also remember me talking about the game Fantasica, a grind-heavy Japanese TCG that plays on my inclination to indulge in the grinding so many JRPGs demand and my obsessive sense of completionism. It is also one of the many free-to-play games out there that backloads the actual cost with incentives to advance. I didn’t originally intend to put any money down on the game, but I have. It only amounted to $28, which I suppose is fair given the number of hours I’ve devoted to it, but not really worth it in the grand scheme of things. At least with physical TCGs, your money gets you actual cards and not just imaginary ones that last as long as the game server’s integrity. I should be happy that I’m not like many players who plunk down $200 or more in one sitting and have nothing to show for it. Perhaps the poor yield during my two experimental stabs at premium content successfully disabused me of the idea of actually getting ahead through paid transactions.

Despite the game lacking any significant plot or characterization beyond the blurb on the back of the cards, I’ve spent a no small percentage of my waking hours on the game since I started back in August. Perhaps the minimal interaction via touchscreen has facilitated this (as it doesn’t cause me the pain of holding a controller). I’ve been late to some classes (the ones I can get away with showing up late) and nearly late to others (the ones that I’d incur a significant penalty for tardiness), which got me to scale back a bit, but it wasn’t until the latest event that really put things in perspective for me.

The guild battle event requires you to physically be present for and participate in five guild battles at set times every day for the duration of the event. I didn’t fully figure this out until the fourth battle of the day yesterday, but the vast majority of my guild was non-participatory as well. The chance of the higher-level rewards was quickly fading from view. However, I was going to make a point to participate in as many as possible, since other guilds can have as significant a participation problem as mine. (For instance, one of the two battles I participated in yesterday had no defenders whatsoever.) The first battle of the day is 0600 CST. I planned on being awake for it (despite having gone to bed at 0430) and then catching a little more sleep until the next one at 1100 and I planned on continuing this pattern until the end of the even next Thursday. In theory, I would only be missing four battles due to classes and I might just be able to rack up enough victories to score my first six-star card.

This was the plan, but it was after 0900 when I woke up. My alarm didn’t work for some reason (or I just slept through it until it gave up). By grinding for an item called Blue Souls, you can raise the morale of your guild and have more action points during a battle. This resets after each battle, so it would’ve made sense to just grind until 1100. However, I decided I’d instead get another hour’s sleep. While I was lying on the couch trying to squeeze in that little extra rest, I realized how foolish it was to let a game (and not a very satisfying one at that) dictate my schedule. I promptly deleted the game and went back to bed.

When it comes to addiction, oftentimes efforts to wean yourself off the source of your addiction or to apply less harmful substitutes only facilitate a relapse. I’m not going to say it works for everyone, but the cold turkey approach gives your system the sufficient shock that–if you get through it–you have a good chance of kicking the habit once and for all. It was what my dad had to do to get off chewing tobacco and what I’m doing to get off an inane TCG.

My obsessive-compulsive addiction with regards to gaming has countless examples. My youth was filled with gaming binges. I remember Christmas break of ’98, where I played Xenogears all day until about 0400 in the morning, caught a little sleep and picked right back up as soon as I woke up. During my brief time playing WoW, I’d clock crazy hours on the grind until the gank-happy Hordies drove me away. Even more recently, after getting the PS2 rerelease of Dragon Force in Japan last year (a game I’d wanted ever since I saw a review for the original Saturn version back in ’96), I’d pull all-nighters going through a character’s scenario (until the pace dropped off in the third act) in multiple playthroughs. The damage to my hands is one of the main things curbing my gaming addiction, but so is my disenchantment with the current tangent of the games industry. (The lack of funds to feed the habit also play a role.) Nevertheless, this sort of behavior is very disturbing to me and I’m glad I’ve refrained from any other habit-forming activities.

I don’t plan on ever becoming a parent, but if I did, I wouldn’t ban my kids from playing video games. I would, however, regulate usage. When I was really little, my mom did the same and as I got older and more independent, I was able to skate by even as my usage increased. Even now, I can get away with quite a bit, but just because you can get away with feeding an addiction doesn’t mean that you should.

Oct 09 2013

No Progress While Standing at the Crossroads

I haven’t made any progress the past couple days because I’ve been preoccupied not only with my everyday stuff but also the developments in my potential paths for next year. There are four main options I have to consider, two of which involve furthering my education. Just moments ago, I withdrew my application for one after concluding it was financially infeasible. I’ll be looking into financing for the other in a few weeks once I find out if my current gig is going to pan out the way I’m hoping or not.

Ever since high school, I’ve scarcely stayed in any one spot for more than two years. That being said, it feels like only yesterday that my previous Japan venture fell apart and I had to return home in defeat. I managed to make the most of it, though, and though my footing is still a little uncertain, I’m ready to try for something new. I don’t know how things will shape up or how they’ll affect my writing career, but you never can tell.

I have a strange pseudo-fatalistic view of the universe. I believe in endless possibilities but ultimately only one path that you follow. We each have a path that we are supposed to follow, but our ultimate purpose may not come to fruition anytime soon. Somewhat paradoxically, I’m a firm believer in free will. We have our set path, but we make the choices that put us on that path. When faced with multiple options, we just have to grope about in the dark until we find the track. I believe I’ve just resolved one branch that wasn’t meant to be. One down, two go.

Sep 07 2013

Antisocial Behavior in Social Gaming

I have always been more of a solitary figure. I no doubt would’ve been a total recluse if I didn’t have my sister and cousins for playmates growing up. Even still, the reclusive impulse is strong. My experience in the Army taught me how to be superficially social for survival purposes and I’ve become quite adept at appearing rather extroverted in public presentation while remaining at heart a committed introvert.

As such, when I play video games, my preferred experience is the single player one (unless we’re talking about Smash Brothers or Mario Kart; the more the merrier then). You can no doubt imagine that the MMO boom hasn’t really held much appeal to me. However, while my battle buddy was deployed to Iraq, I wound up picking up Guild Wars and later WoW to keep him company. (A small service to serve from the comfort of Fort Livingroom.)

Despite the massively multiplayer nature of either of these two games, my impulse (when said battle buddy wasn’t around) was to solo. This was less of a problem in Guild Wars (until my chara hit the level cap while the enemies continued to rise in level) than it was in WoW, because I was stuck on a PvP server. There are warmer climes each and every member of the Horde can be consigned to as far as I’m concerned. I am, of course, talking about the practice of ganking. (Random player-killing to the uninitiated.) Having some dillweed forty levels higher than you come by and kill you whilst questing in contested territory is about as fun as it sounds. It finally became too much for me and I quite the game. (Considering the conniptions my battle buddy would have years later despite being rather accomplished in the game shows that it didn’t just bother me.)

Now, of course the ganking was entirely mutual. Both factions were equally guilty of preying on the weak (though you are naturally going to see the enemy as the more evil). It’s classic predatory behavior, a lot of the crocodile brain at work, I’m sure.

The reason I’m bringing up this topic is because of a similar, albeit more benign variation I’m seeing in Fantasica, which has been occupying no small portion of my time lately. You are free to attack other players once an hour, five of your party and five of your allies versus your opponent’s monsters and vice versa should you find yourself the defender. The typical monsters get chewed up in short order even if you devote the time to maxing them out. Normally, the reward for victory is 10K Luna (the standard in-game currency). You can also target the artifacts an opponent carries to complete your set and get the monster card reward. Because the artifacts you win from the end chapter battles in the main questline are random, you pretty much have to resort to raids to reliably round out your collection. When attacked, though, there’s a report of it, which leaves the defender open to launch a revenge attack and reclaim the lost Luna. (Oh, yes, I failed to mention that the 10K Luna reward comes out of the defender’s coffers.) To prevent the cycle of revenge from going on forever, the game caps the number of attacks on a single player to three in a day.

When it comes to yours truly, I’ve found that I can be rather vindictive soul. If attacked, I will revenge myself three times over, even if the attack is itself revenge for one of my raids. I’ve already had two victims of my depredations plead with me to cease. The most recent even offered to pay me off to get me to stop, but it was never about the money. It was simple vendetta.

Those of you casting a dubious eye on my humanity may be mildly comforted to know that I’ve shown mercy to my supplicants and having reached the end of the current questline, I have no further need to go out a-viking. I’ll still wage a campaign of revenge on any who attack me, but online games have a way of bringing out your inner sociopath.

Aug 31 2013

Unsolicited Game Ideas and Funny Coincidences

It was back in ’96-’97 that I got my start on the Internet, right when it was first starting to get big. I’d actually accessed the Internet for the very first time the year before when I accompanied my dad to the university library. The Internet was quite the different place back then, but that’s only tangential to today’s story.

Being a dumb kid, I thought I could actually submit suggestions to Nintendo for game ideas. For any of you who’ve ever tried this, you’ve probably seen their standard line about not accepting any unsolicited game ideas. Remember that this was back in the ’96-’97 range and think about these two I sent the Big N’s way.

One idea was to have a fighting game with all the major Nintendo characters. Sound familiar? Admittedly, there wasn’t much to the idea, so it’d be silly for me to make any more of it than it is.

More interesting is this next one. I’d read an article on the Metroid Database about the similarities between the Metroid and Alien series. (They admittedly took a rather facile out for comparing Super Metroid and Alien 3, but we can just gloss over that.) I pointed this out in my e-mail to Nintendo and, taking Alien Resurrection into consideration, posited that it might be interesting if Samus was hybridized with Metroid DNA. Besides the standard line, the person who responded claimed that comparisons between Metroid and Alien were quite a stretch. Well, what would grace us in ’02 but the fourth entry into the Metroid series, Metroid Fusion. And guess what happens in it? That’s right. Samus being hybridized with Metroid DNA is a major plot point. Also, the failed military experiment to use the Metroids as bioweapons also dovetails nicely with the premise of Alien Resurrection. Quite a stretch, huh? Yeah, right.

No, I’m not claiming Nintendo took my ideas and ran with them. It’s just a funny coincidence that makes for an amusing anecdote.

Now, here’s one that I simply thought of and almost came to pass. In the Zelda series, you have a string of Links and Zeldas that emerge over the course of history, but only one Ganon. Well, I thought of an idea that might shake things up and play with the themes of fate and such in the series. More or less, Ganon is evil because his lust for power consumes him. Corrupted as he is, he’s nevertheless the exemplar for the Triforce of Power and it’s no doubt his connection to the Triforce of Power that keeps him coming back over and over again. While Link and Zelda represent the Triforce of Courage and Wisdom respectively, they still die and that affinity manifests itself in a new Link and Zelda when the time is ripe. Whether these successive Links and Zeldas are reincarnations or simply manifestations tailored to possess this affinity is uncertain. (If any of this is clarified in the Hyrule Historia, I wouldn’t know as I haven’t read it.) Anyway, my idea was this: What if we had a new incarnation of Ganon, born of different circumstances but still bound by the destiny of the Triforce? Would he still necessarily turn evil?

Our premise begins with Link being accepted into knight training alongside his longtime friend/rival Dorf. Now, the knights are of course dedicated to the defense of the realm but the most elite become the Royal Guard. Enter Princess Zelda. Link and Dorf are both smitten with her and their already competitive natures are kicked into hyperdrive. Zelda isn’t an entirely detached party either. She finds herself developing a strange affinity for these two young recruits, both attractive to her in their own way. On the surface, this looks like simple biology at work, but on a deeper level, it’s their affinity to the Triforce that’s drawing them together.

From there, I could see Link and Dorf’s competition getting increasingly brutal. Dorf is arguably the superior of the two, but Link’s dogged tenacity keeps him right at Dorf’s heels. That sort of tenacity, coupled with his more humble bearing, wins Link Zelda’s favor. When Link and Dorf graduate and join the Guard, Zelda offers herself to Link, but bound to his duty, Link rebuffs her advances. Dorf sees his opportunity to sweep up the crestfallen Zelda, but even with his clumsy attempts to show that he can dial down his aggressive nature, he gets rejected. This is the last straw. If Zelda won’t give herself to him, he’ll take her.

My concept actually goes on to have four different branches for the storyline, two “light side” and two “dark side” paths, but I won’t get into that here. Now, if the gears in your head are turning a bit and if you stretch it a bit, some of those ideas might seem a little familiar.

In Skyward Sword, you have Link in knight training. There’s a love triangle involving Zelda and the proto-Gerudo-looking Groose. Now, Groose was all hot air and wound up turning things around and becoming a genuine friend to Link and the love triangle thing never went anywhere (and for that matter, most of what made the initial sequence interesting was left to wither on the vine). Did Nintendo use its mind readers to absorb my idea and then executive meddling hacked it to ribbons? Not bloody likely. Again, just a funny coincidence and an amusing anecdote.