Jul 11 2025

Fan Theory: That Dude Was My Lady

Warning: Spoilers and wild speculation for Ghost & Lady ahead.

This is going to be a post with very narrow niche appeal, but hear me out. Wednesday my school had its annual cultural activity as a way to relax a bit after term exams and broaden the kiddos’ horizon a bit. The third years (seniors by American standards) went to see the musical adaptation of Ghost & Lady by Kazuhiro Fujita of Ushio & Tora fame. This little fan theory I’ve cooked up relates to the male MC Grey’s backstory. When Grey was alive, he fell in love with an actress named Charlotte who was the mistress of a nobleman. Eventually he asked Charlotte to marry him, but on the day when they were supposed to run off and elope, he is met by a duelist who introduces himself as “d’Eon de Beaumont” and informs Jack (Grey) that Charlotte ran off with her main squeeze and said main squeeze sent d’Eon to take care of his rival. D’Eon is of course the (in)famous Chevalier d’Eon, who acts as the dragon for big bad John Hall.

Let’s put on our tinfoil hats for a moment and consider something. The Chevalier d’Eon’s real name also happens to be Charlotte. Charlotte’s a common enough name, but what if it’s no coincidence? The Chevalier d’Eon was a spy and what better place to hone the craft of assuming a false persona than in a theater troupe? (Consider that Kip Marlowe was also a spy, so who knows how many daggone theater kids were dabbling in espionage back in those days?) A lot of time when crafting cover identities, you weave in some truth to make it easier to keep things consistent. At the time, d’Eon was primarily presenting herself as a man, so using her birth name isn’t all that compromising. Maybe the nobleman who was her paramour was her mark or a way of getting to her mark. Regardless, there was advantage to be had there. Jack was just a bit of fun on the side, but then he got serious, and that made him a liability. And so Charlotte takes up her identity as Charles to tie up the loose end. When she says Charlotte betrayed him, she wasn’t lying. To take it a bit farther, what if she actually did have some genuine feelings for Jack and there was guilt that ate at her over the years which led to her becoming a ghost. I mean, it would explain how familiar d’Eon seemed to be around Grey, and add a layer of tragedy to their final duel. I’m not saying that’s what Fujita intended, but it’s something to think about.

No Comments

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment